Right to Light Injunctions: When the Courts Stop a Building

An injunction is the primary remedy for an infringed right to light. It can stop a building before it starts, halt it part way or order part of a finished building to come down. This guide explains when the courts grant one, when they award damages instead and what the leading cases say.

The starting point

A right to light is a property right. The normal way the courts protect property rights is by an order, not by a payment. If a building infringes the right, the owner of the right is in principle entitled to an injunction requiring the infringement to stop. That has been the law for well over a century and the Supreme Court restated it in 2014. Damages instead of an injunction are the exception. A developer who assumes the exception will apply is taking a risk with the whole scheme.

Kinds of injunction

  • An interim injunction, granted early in a claim to stop work while the case is decided. The claimant normally has to undertake to compensate the developer if the claim is later lost, which makes it a serious step.
  • A final prohibitory injunction, preventing the building or the infringing part of it being built.
  • A mandatory injunction, requiring part of a building that has already been built to be altered or removed.

When damages are awarded instead

In Shelfer v City of London Electric Lighting (1895) the Court of Appeal said damages might be given instead of an injunction where the injury to the claimant’s right is small, can be estimated in money, can be adequately compensated by a small payment and where an injunction would be oppressive to the defendant. For a century those four points were applied almost as a checklist. In Coventry v Lawrence (2014) the Supreme Court said they should not be, that the court has a real discretion and that the public interest and the conduct of the parties can be weighed. The starting point is still that the claimant is entitled to an injunction, but a court is now more willing to look at the whole picture.

What that means in practice is that nobody can say in advance which way a given case would go. Any actionable infringement is potentially injunctable. A surveyor can measure the loss and say whether it is likely to be actionable; whether a court would grant an injunction or award damages in a particular case is a legal judgement for a solicitor and, ultimately, the judge.

The cases where buildings were cut back

Regan v Paul Properties (2006): the Court of Appeal granted an injunction to a homeowner whose living room would have lost a large part of its light to a development across the street, overturning the trial judge who had awarded damages. The developer had to alter the building.

HKRUK II v Heaney (2010): the owner of a Leeds office building had already built two extra floors when the neighbour sued. The court granted a mandatory injunction requiring the infringing parts to be removed, despite the building being complete and despite the neighbour’s delay. The case settled before the appeal, but it changed how developers and their insurers viewed the risk of building first and negotiating later.

Ottercroft v Scandia Care (2016): a metal external staircase caused a small loss of light to a neighbouring restaurant. The loss was minor and could have been compensated cheaply, but the developer had broken an undertaking not to build and the Court of Appeal upheld an injunction requiring the staircase to be moved. Conduct mattered more than the size of the loss.

Beaumont Business Centres v Florala (2020): a serviced office operator in the City sued over an extension that reduced light to rooms that were already poorly lit. The court found an actionable infringement and indicated that an injunction would be granted unless the parties agreed damages, which it assessed at a substantial sum. The case confirmed that a room with poor light can still be protected and that a claimant’s own commercial motives do not disqualify a claim.

Our cases page summarises these and the other leading decisions.

Why delay matters

A court considering an injunction looks at how the claimant behaved. A neighbour who raised the matter promptly, made their position clear in writing and did not stand by while the money was spent is in a strong position. A neighbour who said nothing until the roof was on, hoping to extract a better price, is not. They may find the court more inclined to award damages. The practical lesson for a neighbour is to have the light position checked as soon as the drawings appear and to put the developer on notice early. The lesson for a developer is that a neighbour’s silence is not consent.

Where the surveyor fits

No injunction is granted without evidence of the loss. That evidence is a rights of light report prepared to the Waldram method, showing room by room what the building takes. We prepare those reports for neighbours and for developers. In most matters they lead to a settlement rather than a hearing. Our guide to compensation explains how the figures in the report become a release payment.

If you are facing a scheme next door, send us the drawings or the planning reference. We will tell you within a working day whether your windows look affected and what the sensible next step is. The first conversation is free and there is no obligation to go further.

Frequently asked questions

5

Can I get an injunction to stop my neighbour building?

If the building infringes a right to light you have, an injunction is the primary remedy and a court can grant one. Whether it would in your case depends on the facts and is for a solicitor to advise on.

5

Can a court order a finished building to be demolished?

Part of one, yes. HKRUK v Heaney in 2010 is the best known example, where completed floors were ordered to be removed.

5

What is the Shelfer test?

The four questions from an 1895 case used to decide whether damages could replace an injunction: small injury, measurable in money, adequately compensated by a small payment and an injunction would be oppressive. Since 2014 they are factors, not a checklist.

5

Do I need a solicitor to get an injunction?

Yes. An injunction is a court order and the claim has to be brought and argued by a solicitor and counsel, with a surveyor’s report as the evidence of the loss.

Get in Touch

We will be in touch to discuss your situation within one working day, free of charge.

    *Note - We will not share your personal details with any third parties, and you will not receive any email communication from us outside of direct correspondence in relation to your enquiry.

    Our Location

    Blue Sky Surveyors
    Office 7, 35-37 Ludgate Hill
    London
    EC4M 7JN

    Contact Information

    Phone: +020 7867 3955
    Email: info@rightsoflightsurveyors.co.uk

    Right to Light Injunctions: When the Courts Stop a Building