Right to Light Law in England and Wales Explained
A right to light is a private legal right, not a planning rule. This guide sets out where it comes from, how a property acquires one, what counts as an infringement, what the courts can do about it and how it differs from the daylight tests a council applies.
What a right to light is
A right to light is an easement. It is a right that one property enjoys over another, in the same family as a right of way. The owner of the property with the windows, the dominant owner, is entitled to receive enough natural light through those windows for the ordinary use of the rooms behind them. The owner of the land the light passes over, the servient owner, cannot build in a way that cuts that light below the level the law protects.
Three points follow from this and they surprise people. The right belongs to the windows, not to the garden, so there is no right to light over open land or to sunshine on a lawn. The right is to sufficient light, not to all the light a window has ever had, so a reduction is only actionable if what is left is inadequate. And the right is private, so the council has no part in it and a planning permission does not take it away.
How a right to light is acquired
Most rights to light are acquired by prescription under the Prescription Act 1832. Section 3 provides that where light has been enjoyed through a window for twenty years without interruption, the right becomes absolute and indefeasible, unless the light was enjoyed under a written agreement. There is no need to register anything or to prove that anyone intended to grant a right. The window simply has to have been there, letting in light, for twenty years. Our guide to the Prescription Act and the twenty year rule covers the detail, including what counts as an interruption.
A right can also be created expressly in a deed, implied when land is divided and the seller keeps or sells a building whose windows look over the rest, or claimed under the old doctrine of lost modern grant, which the courts still use where the 1832 Act does not fit. Older documents sometimes exclude rights of light. A lease or transfer that reserves the right to build on adjoining land can stop one arising. A solicitor checks the title; a surveyor measures the light.
What counts as an infringement
The test comes from Colls v Home and Colonial Stores (1904). The question is whether, after the new building goes up, the room still receives enough light for its ordinary use according to the ordinary notions of mankind. The courts have accepted a measured way of answering that question, developed by Percy Waldram in the 1920s and still used today. A point in a room is treated as adequately lit if it can see enough sky to receive one lumen per square foot, which is a sky factor of 0.2 per cent. The surveyor plots the line at desk height, 850 millimetres above the floor, dividing the part of the room that is adequately lit from the part that is not, before and after the proposed building.
The working rule that came out of that method is that a room which keeps at least half of its area adequately lit is unlikely to have a good claim. A room that drops below half, or that loses a substantial part of an already poorly lit area, may have one. Our guide to the Waldram diagram and the 50/50 rule explains how the figures are produced and where the rule of thumb gives way to judgement.
Rights of light and planning are separate
When a council assesses daylight it uses the BRE guide and tests such as the vertical sky component. Those tests decide whether a scheme is acceptable in planning terms. They do not decide whether a right to light is infringed. The thresholds are different too. It is common for a scheme to sit within the BRE guidance and still infringe a neighbour’s right to light. Occasionally it is the other way round. A grant of planning permission, even after a daylight report, leaves the neighbour’s private right exactly where it was.
What a court can do
The primary remedy for an infringement is an injunction. A court can order that a building is not started, is stopped or, in cases such as HKRUK II v Heaney (2010), that part of a completed building is taken down. The court has a discretion to award damages instead of an injunction. Since the Supreme Court’s decision in Coventry v Lawrence (2014) that discretion is wider than it used to be, but an injunction remains the starting point and a developer cannot assume that money will be enough. Any actionable infringement is potentially injunctable. Which remedy a court would grant in a given case is for the court. An owner who wants to pursue a claim should take a solicitor’s advice.
In practice most matters never reach court. The developer’s surveyor and the neighbour’s surveyor agree the figures. The developer either changes the design, pays for a release of the right or arranges rights of light insurance. Our guide to compensation explains how a release payment is usually worked out. Our guide to injunctions looks at the cases where the courts have stopped a building.
Stopping a right from arising
A landowner who expects to build one day can prevent a neighbour’s windows from reaching twenty years. The traditional way was to put up a physical screen. The Rights of Light Act 1959 replaced that with a paper equivalent, the light obstruction notice, registered as a local land charge after a certificate from the Upper Tribunal. Our guide to the 1959 Act and light obstruction notices explains how one is obtained and what it does.
Rights to light in Wales, Scotland and elsewhere
The law described here applies in England and Wales. Scotland has no equivalent right to light by prescription. Schemes there are dealt with through planning and title conditions. Northern Ireland has its own property legislation. We work across England and Wales.
Where to start
If you are a neighbour, the first step is to find out whether your windows are likely to be affected at all, which we can tell you from the planning drawings. If you are building, the first step is to find out which windows around the site have been there for twenty years and what the proposed massing does to them. Either way the first conversation with us is free.
If you are facing a scheme next door, send us the drawings or the planning reference. We will tell you within a working day whether your windows look affected and what the sensible next step is. The first conversation is free and there is no obligation to go further.
Related guides
The Prescription Act 1832 and the 20 year rule | The Rights of Light Act 1959 and light obstruction notices | Ancient lights | The Waldram diagram and the 50/50 rule | Right to light compensation | Right to light injunctions | Key rights of light cases
How we can help
Rights of light surveyors London | Rights of light reports | Help for neighbours | Help for developers | Free first conversation
Frequently asked questions
Is there a right to light in the UK?
In England and Wales, yes. A window that has enjoyed light for twenty years normally has a legal right to it under the Prescription Act 1832. Scotland does not recognise the same right.
Does planning permission override a right to light?
No. Planning permission is a public law consent and a right to light is a private property right. A scheme can be approved by the council and still be stopped, or made to pay, for infringing a neighbour’s light.
Do I have a right to light over my garden?
No. The right protects light to the windows of a building. Sunlight to a garden is a planning consideration under the BRE guide but it is not a private right.
How much light am I entitled to?
Enough for the ordinary use of the room. The courts measure that with the Waldram method. A room that keeps at least half its floor area adequately lit at desk height is usually treated as still having enough.
Can a right to light be lost?
Yes. It can be released by agreement, abandoned if the window is permanently blocked up, interrupted before twenty years by a physical screen or a light obstruction notice, or excluded by the wording of a deed.
What is the difference between right to light and daylight and sunlight?
Daylight and sunlight is the planning assessment carried out under the BRE guide for the council. Right to light is the private legal right between owners. They use different tests and one does not decide the other.
Get in Touch
We will be in touch to discuss your situation within one working day, free of charge.
Our Location
Office 7, 35-37 Ludgate Hill
London
EC4M 7JN
Contact Information
Email: info@rightsoflightsurveyors.co.uk