Vertical Sky Component (VSC) Explained

The vertical sky component is the figure that decides most daylight arguments at planning. This guide explains what it measures, where the 27 per cent and 0.8 targets come from, why a window in a city rarely reaches the target and how a low VSC result is argued.

What VSC measures

The vertical sky component is the amount of daylight falling on the outside of a window from the sky, expressed as a percentage of the daylight that would fall on an unobstructed horizontal surface under the same sky. It is measured at the centre of the window, on the outer face of the wall, under the standard overcast sky used for daylight calculations. Because a vertical surface can only see half the sky, the maximum possible value is a little under 40 per cent, which is what a window with nothing at all in front of it scores.

It is a measure of the window, not the room. It does not depend on the size of the window, the depth of the room or the colour of the walls. It depends only on how much sky the centre of the window can see, which makes it quick to calculate and easy to compare before and after a new building.

BEFOREAFTERvisible skyexisting building oppositeless skyproposed buildingVSC is measured at the centre of the window on the outside face of the wall. The bigger the obstruction, the smaller the patch of sky and the lower the VSC.
The vertical sky component compares the sky a window can see before and after the new building.

The targets

The BRE guide gives two figures. A window with a VSC of 27 per cent or more will usually have enough daylight for the room behind it, so if the VSC after the development stays at or above 27 per cent the test is met. Where it falls below 27 per cent, the guide compares the after value with the before value. If the after value is at least 0.8 times the before value, the change is unlikely to be noticed. If it is lower than 0.8 times the before value as well as below 27 per cent, the loss of daylight is likely to be noticeable and the guide expects the assessor to say so.

Reports give the ratio to two decimal places, so a window going from 30 to 24 per cent has a ratio of 0.80 and is within the guidance, while a window going from 30 to 23 per cent has a ratio of 0.77 and is not. Small differences matter at the margin, which is why the accuracy of the surrounding model matters.

Why city windows rarely meet 27 per cent

A window on a terraced street in London, facing a three storey terrace across a road of normal width, typically has a VSC in the high teens or low twenties before anything is built. A ground floor window under a balcony or a bay may be in single figures. The 27 per cent figure was derived for suburban densities and the guide acknowledges that in dense urban areas a lower figure may be unavoidable and that targets should be applied flexibly. The London Plan guidance says the same. In practice an officer assessing a scheme in Camden or Southwark looks first at the ratio and then at what the surrounding streets already achieve.

Windows that need extra care

  • Windows under balconies or overhangs, where the guide asks for a second calculation with the balcony removed to show how much of the loss is the balcony’s fault rather than the new building’s
  • Rooms with more than one window, where an area-weighted VSC across the windows can be used, but only where the windows light the same part of the room; a through lounge more than five metres deep should not have its front windows averaged with its rear ones
  • Windows already heavily obstructed, where a modest new building can produce a ratio below 0.8 because the starting figure was so small
  • Non-habitable rooms, bathrooms, halls and stairs, which are not normally tested at all

How a low VSC is argued

A ratio below 0.8 is the start of the discussion, not the end. The guide asks whether the loss is material in the circumstances. The usual points made for an applicant are that the window serves a kitchen or a secondary room, that the room has other windows, that the existing VSC is already poor because of the neighbour’s own balcony or bay, that the surrounding streets show similar figures, or that a mirror-image massing on the applicant’s side of the boundary would produce the same result. The points made for an objector are the reverse, above all that the room is a living room or bedroom with no other source of light. Either way a result that does not meet the BRE recommendations should be reported as such and explained, not hidden in an appendix.

VSC and rights of light

VSC is a planning test. It is not the measure the courts use for a right to light, which is assessed by the Waldram method on the room rather than the window. A window can pass the VSC test and the room behind it still suffer an actionable loss. The reverse is possible too. We run both where a scheme raises both questions.

If you need VSC figures for an application, or a neighbour’s report shows a low ratio on your windows, send us the drawings and we will tell you what the numbers mean.

Frequently asked questions

5

What does a VSC of 27% mean?

That the centre of the window receives about 27 per cent of the light available from the whole sky. The BRE guide treats that as enough for a well daylit room.

5

What is the maximum VSC?

Just under 40 per cent, for a window with nothing in front of it. A vertical surface can only ever see half the sky.

5

Is VSC the same as daylight factor?

No. VSC is measured outside the window and describes the sky available to it. Daylight factor is measured inside the room and depends on the window size, the room and its finishes as well.

5

Can a VSC loss be fixed by design?

Often. Setting the upper floors back, lowering the parapet nearest the affected window or chamfering a corner can lift a ratio from 0.75 to 0.80 without losing much floor area, which is why the assessment is best run before the design is fixed.

Get in Touch

We will be in touch to discuss your situation within one working day, free of charge.

    *Note - We will not share your personal details with any third parties, and you will not receive any email communication from us outside of direct correspondence in relation to your enquiry.

    Our Location

    Blue Sky Surveyors
    Office 7, 35-37 Ludgate Hill
    London
    EC4M 7JN

    Contact Information

    Phone: +020 7867 3955
    Email: info@rightsoflightsurveyors.co.uk

    Vertical Sky Component (VSC) Explained