Daylight and Sunlight Tests Explained

When a council asks for a daylight and sunlight assessment it expects a set of specific tests from the BRE guide, each with its own target. This guide explains what each test measures, what the numbers mean and how the results are read, so that a report makes sense whether you are the applicant or the neighbour.

Where the tests come from

The tests all come from one document, Site Layout Planning for Daylight and Sunlight (BR 209), published by the Building Research Establishment and now in its 2022 third edition. The guide is not law and its figures are guidance rather than limits, but almost every planning authority in England and Wales uses it, the Planning Inspectorate refers to it on appeal and the London Plan is built around it. A daylight and sunlight assessment is simply the BRE tests applied to a particular scheme and written up for the case officer.

The guide looks at two separate things. The first is the effect of a new building on the daylight and sunlight that existing neighbouring buildings and gardens receive. The second is the daylight and sunlight that new homes within the scheme will receive themselves. Most assessments cover the first; schemes creating new dwellings cover both.

Tests for neighbouring windows

Vertical sky component (VSC)

The main daylight test. It measures the amount of sky visible from the centre of a window, as a percentage of the sky that would be visible if nothing stood in the way. A window with nothing in front of it scores just under 40 per cent. The guide says that a window keeping a VSC of at least 27 per cent will still be well lit. Where the VSC after the development is below 27 per cent and below 0.8 times its former value, the loss is likely to be noticed. Our VSC guide goes into the detail.

No sky line (daylight distribution)

VSC looks at the window; the no sky line looks at the room. On a plan of the room at desk height, 0.85 metres above the floor, the surveyor draws the line beyond which no sky can be seen through the window. The area in front of the line is directly daylit. If that area shrinks to less than 0.8 times its former size the change will be noticeable. A deep room lit from one end can show a large movement from a small obstruction, which the guide says should be read sensibly.

Annual and winter probable sunlight hours (APSH)

The sunlight test, applied to windows that face within 90 degrees of due south. It counts the hours of probable sunlight the window centre receives over the year and over the winter half, 21 September to 21 March, as a percentage of the total available. The targets are 25 per cent for the year and 5 per cent for the winter. A window that keeps those, or keeps 0.8 times its former value and loses no more than 4 percentage points over the year, is within the guide. Our sunlight and overshadowing guide explains the numbers.

Overshadowing of gardens and open spaces

For gardens, play areas and sitting-out spaces the guide asks that at least half the area receives at least two hours of sunlight on 21 March, the spring equinox. Where it already receives less, or the area meeting the two hours falls below 0.8 times what it was, the loss is likely to be noticed.

Tests for new homes

For the rooms inside a proposed scheme the 2022 guide follows the British Standard BS EN 17037. Each habitable room is given a target illuminance from daylight alone, 100 lux for bedrooms, 150 lux for living rooms and 200 lux for kitchens, to be met across at least half the room for at least half the daylight hours in the year. In practice that is calculated either by climate-based modelling or as a daylight factor; in London the targets work out at roughly 1, 1.5 and 2 per cent. For sunlight, at least one habitable room, ideally the main living room, should receive at least 1.5 hours of sun on 21 March. Our daylight factor guide covers the method.

The quick checks

Before any of the above, the guide offers two rules of thumb. The 25 degree rule says that a new building below a line drawn at 25 degrees from the centre of the lowest affected window opposite is unlikely to affect its daylight. The 45 degree rule does the same for an extension beside a window. A scheme that passes the quick check usually needs nothing more; a scheme that does not needs the full tests, which may well show it is fine.

How to read the results

A report lists each neighbouring window and room with the before and after figures and the ratio between them. The ratio is the number to watch. Anything at 0.8 or above is within the guide. Below 0.8 the loss is described as noticeable. The guide then asks whether it is also material in the circumstances. A kitchen window that already sits under a deep balcony, a room with other windows that keep it well lit, or a dense urban setting where every window is already below 27 per cent, all change how an officer reads a low ratio. The guide itself says its targets should be applied flexibly. An assessment that explains the context is worth far more than a table of figures with the shortfalls highlighted.

What the tests do not do

None of them decides whether a neighbour has a right to light. That is a private legal right measured by a different method, the Waldram analysis, with different thresholds. A scheme can meet every BRE target and still infringe a right to light. Planning permission does not remove the right. Where both questions arise we run both sets of calculations from the same model.

If you have been asked for an assessment, or you are a neighbour trying to understand one, send us the drawings or the planning reference and we will tell you what the figures mean for your windows.

Frequently asked questions

5

What is a good VSC?

The BRE guide treats 27 per cent or more as good daylight for a window. Below that, the comparison with the former value matters: keeping at least 0.8 of the previous VSC is within the guidance.

5

Are the BRE targets legally binding?

No. They are guidance. Councils and inspectors give them considerable weight but can accept a shortfall where the context justifies it, for example in dense city centres.

5

Which windows are tested?

Windows to habitable rooms in neighbouring buildings that face the site: living rooms, bedrooms, kitchens and dining rooms. Bathrooms, halls and landings are not normally assessed. For sunlight only windows facing within 90 degrees of south count.

5

Do the tests apply to a small extension?

The same tests apply, though a small extension is often dealt with by the 45 degree quick check alone. If it crosses the line, the VSC test on the affected window settles it.

5

How long does an assessment take?

For an extension or small scheme, usually a week from receiving the drawings. Larger schemes with many neighbouring windows take two to three weeks. We quote within 24 hours, Monday to Friday.

Get in Touch

We will be in touch to discuss your situation within one working day, free of charge.

    *Note - We will not share your personal details with any third parties, and you will not receive any email communication from us outside of direct correspondence in relation to your enquiry.

    Our Location

    Blue Sky Surveyors
    Office 7, 35-37 Ludgate Hill
    London
    EC4M 7JN

    Contact Information

    Phone: +020 7867 3955
    Email: info@rightsoflightsurveyors.co.uk

    Daylight and Sunlight Tests Explained