The Waldram Diagram and the 50/50 Rule

Rights of light are measured by a method devised in the 1920s and still accepted by the courts: the Waldram diagram, the 0.2 per cent sky factor and the rule of thumb that a room keeping half its area adequately lit has not suffered an actionable loss. This guide explains how it works and where the rule of thumb gives way to judgement.

Where the method comes from

When the House of Lords decided Colls v Home and Colonial Stores in 1904 it said that a right to light was a right to enough light for the ordinary purposes of the room, judged by ordinary notions. It declined to put a number on it. Percy Waldram, a surveyor, spent the following two decades turning that into something measurable. His method was adopted by the courts in the 1920s and 1930s and, with refinements, it is still the way rights of light are assessed. The planning tests under the BRE guide came much later and are different.

The sky factor and the working plane

Waldram took the view that a point in a room is adequately lit if it receives at least one lumen per square foot from the sky, which under the standard overcast sky equals a sky factor of 0.2 per cent. He measured it at desk height, a working plane 850 millimetres above the floor. For every point on that plane the question is whether the patch of sky visible through the window is big enough to deliver 0.2 per cent. The Waldram diagram is the tool that answers it: a projection of the sky on which the window and every obstruction beyond it are plotted from a given point, so that the unobstructed sky can be read off as an area.

Surveyors no longer draw the diagrams by hand. A three dimensional model of the room, the window and everything outside it is built and the sky factor is calculated on a fine grid across the working plane. The result is the same thing Waldram drew: a contour across the room, the no sky line, dividing the area that receives 0.2 per cent or more from the area that does not.

Before and after

The calculation is run twice, once with the surroundings as they are and once with the proposed building added. The lit area in front of the no sky line shrinks. The difference between the two is the loss of light to the room. It is expressed in square feet or square metres of adequately lit floor area and as a percentage of the room. The result is a plan of the room with two lines on it, which is why rights of light reports look so different from the window-by-window tables in a planning assessment.

The 50/50 rule

Out of the early cases came a rule of thumb. If, after the development, at least half of the room remains adequately lit, the room is unlikely to have a good claim: the ordinary purposes of a room can be served by a well lit half. If less than half remains lit, or the room was already below half and loses more, there may be an actionable injury. This is the 50/50 rule and it is still the first thing a surveyor looks at.

It is a rule of thumb, not a rule of law. Courts have found actionable injury where more than half the room stayed lit, where the loss fell on the part of the room that mattered or the room was unusually large. They have declined to find it where the room fell below half but the loss was small. The figures tell you where the argument is; they do not decide it. Whether a given loss is actionable and what remedy would follow is a matter for a solicitor and, ultimately, a court.

Zones and the value of the loss

Once a loss is identified the report divides the room into zones from the window inwards, because light lost at the front of the room is worth more than light lost at the back. The first zones carry full or extra weight and the rear zones, often called the makeweight, a fraction. The weighted loss, measured as an equivalent area of first zone light, is the figure the two sides use when they discuss a release payment. Our guide to compensation explains how that figure turns into money.

Waldram and the BRE tests

The planning tests, such as the vertical sky component, measure the window from outside and ask whether a loss is noticeable. The Waldram method measures the room from inside and asks whether what is left is enough. They use different skies, different thresholds and different units. A scheme can pass one and not the other, which is why a planning permission with a satisfactory daylight report tells you nothing about the rights of light position.

If you want to know what the Waldram figures say about your rooms or your scheme, our rights of light survey page explains what the work involves.

If you are facing a scheme next door, send us the drawings or the planning reference. We will tell you within a working day whether your windows look affected and what the sensible next step is. The first conversation is free and there is no obligation to go further.

Frequently asked questions

5

What is the 0.2% sky factor?

The amount of sky a point needs to see to receive one lumen per square foot under an overcast sky. Waldram treated that as the minimum for a point to be adequately lit and the courts accepted it.

5

What is the no sky line?

The line across a room at desk height beyond which the 0.2 per cent sky factor is no longer reached. The area in front of it is the adequately lit area. The BRE planning guide uses a similar line for its daylight distribution test, drawn at the point where no sky at all is visible.

5

Is the 50/50 rule the law?

No. It is a surveyor’s rule of thumb derived from the cases and the courts have departed from it in both directions.

5

Does a Waldram assessment need access to the neighbour's rooms?

It helps. Room layouts can be taken from plans or assumed. The report records what was assumed so that it can be corrected if the owner provides better information.

Get in Touch

We will be in touch to discuss your situation within one working day, free of charge.

    *Note - We will not share your personal details with any third parties, and you will not receive any email communication from us outside of direct correspondence in relation to your enquiry.

    Our Location

    Blue Sky Surveyors
    Office 7, 35-37 Ludgate Hill
    London
    EC4M 7JN

    Contact Information

    Phone: +020 7867 3955
    Email: info@rightsoflightsurveyors.co.uk

    The Waldram Diagram and the 50/50 Rule