Right to Light Insurance Explained

Rights of light insurance covers a developer against the cost of a neighbour enforcing a right to light, from damages and legal fees to the cost of changing or cutting back the building. This guide explains what the policies cover, what they exclude, what insurers need to see and when insurance is the wrong answer.

What the policy does

A rights of light indemnity policy is a legal indemnity bought by a developer, or sometimes by a funder or buyer, against the risk that an owner of a neighbouring building enforces a right to light against the scheme. If a claim is made, the policy pays the costs of defending it and any damages or settlement. In the fuller policies it also pays the loss in value or the cost of works if a court orders the building to be altered or part of it removed. The sum insured is normally set at the gross development value or the loss the developer would suffer if the worst happened.

It is a one-off premium, paid before works start, with cover that lasts for the life of the building or a long fixed period and passes to successors in title. Lenders often make it a condition of funding where a rights of light report shows a residual risk.

What it covers and what it excludes

  • Covered: damages awarded to a neighbour, the cost of a negotiated release once a claim has been made, the developer’s own legal costs and the neighbour’s costs if ordered
  • Covered in most policies: the cost of complying with an injunction, including redesign and demolition, with the resulting loss in value
  • Excluded: any neighbour who has already complained, objected on rights of light grounds or been approached about a release before the policy is taken out, unless the insurer agrees to include them
  • Excluded: losses from windows the developer knew about and did not disclose, plus anything outside the scheme as drawn when the policy was written

The conditions that catch people out

Insurers write the policy on the basis that the neighbours do not know they have a claim. The standard conditions follow from that. The developer must not approach the neighbours about rights of light, must not disclose the existence of the policy and must not refer to rights of light in planning documents in a way that invites a claim. Once a neighbour raises the subject, the developer has to notify the insurer and let it run the response. A developer who starts negotiating a release with one neighbour and then tries to insure the rest will find that the neighbour they spoke to is excluded and the premium on the others has gone up.

This creates a decision that has to be made early. Either the developer goes down the route of talking to the neighbours, agreeing releases and paying for them, or goes down the insurance route and keeps quiet. Doing both in the wrong order is expensive.

What drives the premium

The underwriter prices the policy from the rights of light report. The things that move the premium are the number of rooms with an actionable loss, the size of those losses, the use of the affected buildings, with residential treated as more likely to claim than offices, the profile of the neighbours, whether planning permission has been granted and whether anyone has objected on light grounds and the gross development value being insured. A scheme with two small kitchen losses behind a commercial frontage insures cheaply. A scheme that takes most of the light from the living rooms of a block of owner-occupied flats may not insure at all, or only on terms that assume a release will be negotiated first.

What the insurer needs from your surveyor

A rights of light report prepared to the Waldram method, identifying every neighbouring window with a potential right, showing the before and after lit areas for each affected room and scheduling the actionable losses with an assessment of the likely compensation. Insurers also want to know the age and history of the affected buildings, whether any deeds exclude rights of light, whether a light obstruction notice has ever been registered and what the planning history says. We prepare reports in the form underwriters expect and deal with their questions directly.

When insurance is the wrong answer

Insurance transfers the financial risk. It does not remove the neighbour’s right and it does not stop a court granting an injunction. Where a scheme takes a serious amount of light from a home, the realistic outcome of a claim may be an order to cut the building back. A policy that pays for that is paying for a worse building than the one that could have been designed in the first place. In those cases the better route is usually to deal with the neighbour directly: a modest change to the massing, a negotiated release at a known cost, or both. Our guide to compensation explains how release payments are worked out and our guide to injunctions explains when the courts have refused to accept money instead.

If you are planning a scheme, the cheapest time to deal with rights of light is before the design is fixed. Send us the drawings and we will say which neighbouring windows are at risk and what the options are, from adjusting the massing to a release or insurance.

Frequently asked questions

5

How much does rights of light insurance cost?

It is quoted case by case from the rights of light report, as a one-off premium. Small residential schemes with modest losses can be a few thousand pounds; schemes with large losses to homes can be many times that or uninsurable without a release.

5

Can I get insurance after a neighbour has objected?

Not for that neighbour, as a rule. Insurers exclude anyone who has already raised rights of light. Cover may still be available for the other neighbours.

5

Does rights of light insurance protect the neighbour?

No. It is the developer’s policy. A neighbour’s rights are unchanged by it and they are not told it exists.

5

Does planning permission reduce the premium?

Usually, yes. A granted permission with no objections on light shows the insurer that the neighbours have had their chance to raise the issue, though it does not remove the risk.

5

Is insurance an alternative to a rights of light survey?

No. The survey comes first; the insurer prices the policy from it and will not quote without one.

Get in Touch

We will be in touch to discuss your situation within one working day, free of charge.

    *Note - We will not share your personal details with any third parties, and you will not receive any email communication from us outside of direct correspondence in relation to your enquiry.

    Our Location

    Blue Sky Surveyors
    Office 7, 35-37 Ludgate Hill
    London
    EC4M 7JN

    Contact Information

    Phone: +020 7867 3955
    Email: info@rightsoflightsurveyors.co.uk

    Right to Light Insurance Explained