When Does a Planning Application Need a Daylight and Sunlight Assessment?

Councils do not ask for a daylight and sunlight assessment on every application, but they ask for one far more often than applicants expect. This guide sets out when one is needed, scheme by scheme, what it has to show and what to send a surveyor to get it done.

The general rule

A council asks for a daylight and sunlight assessment where a proposal could reduce the daylight or sunlight to neighbouring homes, or where it creates new homes whose own daylight needs to be shown. Most local validation lists say so in those terms. Many add specific triggers: any new dwelling, any building taller than its neighbours, any extension that crosses the 45 degree line. The request can come at validation, when the application is first checked, or from the case officer later, often after a neighbour has objected. An assessment submitted with the application avoids the delay.

The assessment follows the BRE guide and uses its tests: the vertical sky component and no sky line for daylight to neighbours, probable sunlight hours and overshadowing for sunlight, plus the BS EN 17037 targets for new homes. Our guide to the tests explains them.

Single storey rear extensions

Usually not, unless the extension crosses the 45 degree rule from the neighbour’s nearest window. Where it does, a short assessment of that window, showing the vertical sky component before and after, is normally enough and often shows the loss is within the guidance. Extensions on terraces with a neighbouring kitchen window close to the boundary are the common case.

Two storey and side extensions

More often. A two storey rear extension or a side extension that rises beside a neighbour’s window crosses the 45 degree line in elevation as well as plan. The council will want the BRE tests on the affected windows. Side extensions that fill a gap between semi-detached houses affect the neighbour’s side windows, which are often secondary. The assessment is partly about which rooms those windows serve.

Loft conversions and dormers

Rarely. A rear dormer sits high and to one side of the neighbours’ view of the sky and seldom causes a measurable loss. The exception is a hip-to-gable conversion or a raised roof beside a neighbour’s rooflight or high level window.

Basements

Not for daylight to neighbours, since nothing is added above ground. A basement that comes with a raised lightwell structure, a garden room or a rooflight enclosure is assessed on those. Where the basement contains habitable rooms, the council may ask for the daylight to those rooms to be shown, which lightwells often struggle to provide.

A new house in a garden or on an infill plot

Almost always. A new dwelling triggers both halves of the assessment: the effect on the neighbours around the plot and the daylight and sunlight within the new house. Infill plots are by definition tight and the neighbours’ rear windows are close, so the report usually drives the massing. This is the scheme type where getting the assessment done before the design is fixed saves the most money.

Conversions to flats and HMOs

For a conversion of a house into flats the council will usually want the internal daylight to each new habitable room shown against the BS EN 17037 targets, particularly for basement and ground floor rooms and single aspect rooms. The effect on neighbours is normally small unless the conversion adds an extension. HMO applications are treated similarly where the council has a standard for room daylight.

Upward extensions and extra storeys

Yes, whether under full planning or the prior approval route for additional storeys, where the council must consider the effect on the light to neighbouring premises. An extra storey across a street affects the upper floor windows opposite and the report concentrates on those windows and on the daylight to the new flats themselves.

Commercial to residential

Under the Class MA permitted development route the council considers the adequacy of natural light to the habitable rooms of the new homes. A daylight assessment of those rooms is the way to show it. Deep plan offices converted to flats are where shortfalls appear.

Blocks of flats and larger schemes

Always. The assessment covers every neighbouring habitable room window facing the site, every garden and amenity space and every habitable room in the scheme. On a large site it runs to hundreds of windows. The London Plan and most urban local plans expect it as a matter of course.

What to send us

The site address, the drawings, meaning plans, elevations and sections of the proposal, the planning reference if there is one and a copy of anything the council has said about daylight. From that we tell you which windows and rooms need testing and quote within 24 hours, Monday to Friday. For an extension the report is normally ready within a week; for a flatted scheme two to three weeks.

One thing the assessment does not cover

A planning daylight assessment does not address the neighbours’ rights of light, which are tested differently and survive planning permission. Where a scheme stands close to windows that have been there for twenty years we run the rights of light calculation from the same model, so that the planning report and the legal position arrive together.

Frequently asked questions

5

Does a single storey extension need a daylight assessment?

Only where it crosses the 45 degree line from a neighbour’s window or the council asks for one. Where it does, a short report on the affected window usually settles it.

5

Can the council refuse to validate without one?

Yes, where the local validation list requires it for that type of application. Check the list on the council’s website before submitting.

5

Does the assessment have to follow BRE 209?

In practice yes. Councils and inspectors expect the BRE methods and targets. A report that uses anything else will be questioned.

5

How much does a daylight and sunlight assessment cost?

It depends on the number of windows and rooms to be tested. We quote from the drawings within 24 hours, Monday to Friday.

5

Can I use the assessment to answer a neighbour's objection?

Yes. That is one of its main uses: measured figures showing the effect on the objector’s windows carry more weight with the officer than either side’s description.

Get in Touch

We will be in touch to discuss your situation within one working day, free of charge.

    *Note - We will not share your personal details with any third parties, and you will not receive any email communication from us outside of direct correspondence in relation to your enquiry.

    Our Location

    Blue Sky Surveyors
    Office 7, 35-37 Ludgate Hill
    London
    EC4M 7JN

    Contact Information

    Phone: +020 7867 3955
    Email: info@rightsoflightsurveyors.co.uk

    When Does a Planning Application Need a Daylight and Sunlight Assessment?