My Neighbour's Extension Is Blocking My Light: What You Can Do
A planning notice has arrived, or the builders have. The extension next door is going to take the light from your kitchen or living room. There are two separate routes open to you, planning and your private right to light. They work on different timetables. This guide explains both, in the order to take them.
First, find out what is proposed
If you have had a letter from the council, the planning reference on it will take you to the drawings on the council’s planning portal. Look at the rear and side elevations and the section. Note the depth of the extension from the rear wall, its height at the boundary and whether it has a flat or pitched roof. If there is no planning application, ask the neighbour: many single storey extensions are built under permitted development, which changes the planning route but not your private rights.
Route one: the planning objection
The council will decide the application on planning grounds and loss of daylight and sunlight to your windows is one of them. Most councils apply the 45 degree rule to extensions and the BRE tests to anything larger. You can object in writing within the consultation period, normally 21 days from the notice. The useful objection is a specific one: which of your windows, which room it serves, how far the extension projects past it and that it crosses the 45 degree line. Our guide to objecting on loss of light includes a template. For a scheme that will take a serious amount of light, a short daylight report from a surveyor commissioned by you carries far more weight with an officer than a letter.
Be clear about what the planning route can and cannot do. It can get the extension refused, reduced or redesigned. It cannot get you compensation. If permission is granted the council’s decision has no effect on your private right.
Route two: your right to light
If your window has been there for twenty years, it almost certainly has a right to light over the neighbour’s land under the Prescription Act 1832. That right is private, it survives planning permission and it is enforced by you, not the council. The test is whether the room behind the window keeps enough light for its ordinary use, measured by the Waldram method; the rule of thumb is that a room keeping at least half its area adequately lit has not suffered an actionable loss. A kitchen or bedroom with one window beside the new wall is the situation in which that line is most often crossed. Our worked examples show the typical outcomes.
The first step is a rights of light survey of your affected rooms. It tells you whether there is a loss worth pursuing and how large it is. If there is, the realistic options are to agree with the neighbour that the design is changed, to agree a payment for releasing your right over the extension as drawn, or to take legal advice about stopping the work. Any actionable infringement is potentially injunctable; whether a court would grant an injunction or award damages in your case is for the court. A solicitor should advise you before you threaten either.
If the extension is permitted development
Permitted development means no planning application and no objection, except under the larger home extension scheme where the council must consider neighbours’ amenity if you object to the prior approval notice. Your right to light is unaffected by any of this. A neighbour building under permitted development is in exactly the same position as one with planning permission: if the extension infringes your right, you can act on it.
If work has already started
Starting work does not remove your right. A completed extension can still be the subject of a claim, as the courts have shown by ordering buildings to be cut back. But delay weakens your position. A court weighs how quickly you raised the matter. A neighbour who has spent the money is harder to negotiate with than one who has not. If the scaffolding is up, get the position checked that week, write to the neighbour setting out your concern and keep a copy. Do not wait for the roof to go on.
What not to do
- Do not assume planning permission settles it. It does not.
- Do not sign anything from the neighbour or their builder, including a party wall consent that mentions light, without advice. A party wall award does not deal with rights of light, but a badly worded letter can.
- Do not rely on the neighbour’s own daylight report. It was written for them and uses the planning tests, not the legal one.
- Do not let the twenty years slip if you are close to it: a light obstruction notice served now can stop your right arising.
- Do not threaten an injunction you have not taken advice on.
Costs
The first conversation with us is free and we will tell you from the drawings whether your windows look affected before you spend anything. Where a survey shows an actionable loss and the matter settles, the developer commonly pays the neighbour’s reasonable surveying and legal costs as part of the settlement, separately from any compensation. Our guide to compensation explains how a release payment is worked out.
If you are facing a scheme next door, send us the drawings or the planning reference. We will tell you within a working day whether your windows look affected and what the sensible next step is. The first conversation is free and there is no obligation to go further.
Related guides
Right to light law explained | How to object to a planning application on loss of light | The 45 degree rule | Right to light compensation | Right to light injunctions | What a rights of light survey involves
How we can help
Help for neighbours | Rights of light surveyors London | Areas we cover | Free first conversation
Frequently asked questions
Can my neighbour build an extension that blocks my light?
They can apply for permission and may get it, but if your window has a right to light and the extension takes the room below the level the law protects, you can enforce the right regardless of the permission.
How much light can a neighbour take?
For planning, the council looks at the 45 degree rule and the BRE tests. For your private right, the courts look at whether the room keeps enough light for ordinary use, with half the room adequately lit as the usual threshold.
Does a party wall notice cover loss of light?
No. The Party Wall etc. Act 1996 deals with structural works to shared walls and near boundaries. It does not deal with light. The party wall surveyors will not assess it.
Can I stop the work?
Possibly, through the courts, if the extension infringes your right. That is a legal step on which a solicitor must advise. It depends on the size of the loss and how promptly you act.
What if the extension is already built?
Your right survives. Courts have ordered completed buildings to be altered. Settlements are reached after completion, but the sooner you act the stronger your position.
Get in Touch
We will be in touch to discuss your situation within one working day, free of charge.
Our Location
Office 7, 35-37 Ludgate Hill
London
EC4M 7JN
Contact Information
Email: info@rightsoflightsurveyors.co.uk