What a Rights of Light Survey Involves
A rights of light survey tells you whether a proposed building will cut the light to neighbouring windows below the level the law protects, which rooms are affected and by how much. Here is what the surveyor does, what you get at the end and when in a project it is worth commissioning.
What the survey is for
A rights of light survey answers one question: will this building infringe a neighbour’s right to light. It is a technical exercise with a legal purpose. The surveyor measures how much light each affected room receives now, how much it will receive once the proposed building is up and whether the difference crosses the line the courts use. The same survey serves both sides. A developer commissions it to find out what the scheme can get away with and what it will cost to settle. A neighbour commissions it to find out whether there is anything worth pursuing.
Step one: which windows have a right
Not every window next to a site has a right to light. The surveyor identifies the windows that look towards the site and works out, with the help of old maps, planning records and sometimes a solicitor’s review of the title, which of them have been in place for twenty years. A window in a 1930s semi almost certainly has a right. A window in a block finished five years ago does not yet, unless the building replaced an older one with windows in the same place, in which case the earlier windows’ rights can carry across. Deeds are also checked for clauses that exclude or reserve rights of light.
Step two: the model
The surveyor builds a three dimensional model of the proposed building, the affected properties and everything else around them that blocks sky, including existing buildings, roofs, chimneys and parapets. The accuracy of the model decides the accuracy of everything that follows, so we carry out our own measured survey of the site and the neighbouring elevations with a laser scanner rather than relying on drawings alone. For the rooms behind the windows we use floor plans where owners will provide them and standard assumptions where they will not. A room we cannot see is modelled on a reasonable layout and the report says so.
Step three: the calculation
The test the courts recognise is the Waldram method. For each room the model works out the sky factor at points on a grid at desk height, 850 millimetres above the floor. Any point that can see enough sky to receive at least one lumen per square foot, a sky factor of 0.2 per cent, counts as adequately lit. The result is a contour, the no sky line, dividing the lit part of the room from the unlit part. The calculation is run twice, once with the existing surroundings and once with the proposed building in place. The two lines are compared. Our guide to the Waldram diagram and the 50/50 rule goes into the figures.
Step four: deciding what is actionable
A room that keeps at least half of its area adequately lit after the development is usually treated as suffering no actionable loss. A room that falls below half, or that loses a large part of an already small lit area, is flagged. The report sets out, room by room, the lit area before, the lit area after and the loss. It divides the loss into zones that reflect how valuable the lost light is. Light lost from the front of the room near the window weighs more than light lost at the back. Those weighted figures are what the two sides later use to agree compensation if the developer decides to build and pay rather than redesign. Our guide to compensation explains how that works.
What the report contains
- A plan of the site with every neighbouring window that may have a right to light marked and numbered
- The basis on which each window is treated as having a right, with any windows excluded and why
- For each affected room, the before and after no sky lines on a plan, with the lit areas and the loss in square feet or metres
- A schedule showing which rooms suffer an actionable loss and the weighted loss for each
- For developers, options: the cut back that would remove the actionable losses, the likely scale of a release payment and whether insurance is realistic
- For neighbours, a plain statement of whether there is a case worth pursuing and what to do next
When to commission one
For a developer the right time is before the design is fixed, usually at feasibility or at the latest before the planning application. At that stage a storey can be lowered or a bay set back at the cost of a few drawings. After planning, the same change means a new application. After construction starts, the options narrow to paying or, in the worst case, taking part of the building down. For a neighbour the right time is as soon as the drawings are available, which is usually when the planning application appears. Waiting until the scaffolding goes up does not remove your right, but it does make the conversation harder and the developer less willing to move.
What it does not cover
A rights of light survey is not a daylight and sunlight assessment for planning. The council’s tests under the BRE guide use different measurements, the vertical sky component and others. They answer a different question. Where both are needed we run both from the same model, which saves the client paying for the surroundings to be measured twice. The survey also does not tell you what a court would do. Any actionable infringement is potentially injunctable; whether a court would grant an injunction or award damages in a given case is a legal question for your solicitor.
What we need from you
The site address, the proposed drawings (plans, elevations and sections) and the planning reference if there is one. For a neighbour, a note of which of your rooms face the site and roughly when the house was built. From that we can say within a working day whether a full survey is justified.
If you are facing a scheme next door, send us the drawings or the planning reference. We will tell you within a working day whether your windows look affected and what the sensible next step is. The first conversation is free and there is no obligation to go further.
Related guides
Right to light law explained | The Waldram diagram and the 50/50 rule | Right to light compensation | Right to light insurance | My neighbour’s extension is blocking my light
How we can help
Rights of light reports | Rights of light surveyors London | Help for neighbours | Help for developers | Areas we cover
Frequently asked questions
How long does a rights of light survey take?
A desktop assessment from drawings can be turned round in a few days. A full survey with a measured site visit, the model and the report normally takes two to three weeks from instruction, depending on access to the neighbouring properties.
Do you need to go inside the neighbouring properties?
It helps but it is not essential. Room layouts can be taken from estate agents’ plans, planning records or reasonable assumptions. Where we have had to assume a layout the report says so. The figures can be updated if the owner later provides plans.
Is a rights of light survey the same as a party wall survey?
No. Party wall surveyors deal with the structural works to a shared wall or near a boundary under the Party Wall etc. Act 1996. They do not assess light. A party wall award says nothing about a right to light.
Can I rely on the developer's rights of light report?
It will have been prepared for the developer and will reflect their instructions and assumptions. Most neighbours have the figures checked by their own surveyor. In a settlement the developer normally pays that surveyor’s reasonable fees.
Do I need a solicitor as well as a surveyor?
For the measurement and negotiation, a surveyor. For the title check, the deed of release and any court proceedings, a solicitor. On most matters the surveyor does the early work and brings a solicitor in when the paperwork or a claim needs it.
Get in Touch
We will be in touch to discuss your situation within one working day, free of charge.
Our Location
Office 7, 35-37 Ludgate Hill
London
EC4M 7JN
Contact Information
Email: info@rightsoflightsurveyors.co.uk