BRE 209 Explained: The Daylight and Sunlight Guide

BR 209, Site Layout Planning for Daylight and Sunlight, is the document behind every daylight and sunlight assessment in England and Wales. This guide explains what it is, what changed in the 2022 third edition, how councils use it, what its targets are and why it should be read as guidance rather than a pass or fail test.

What BRE 209 is

Site Layout Planning for Daylight and Sunlight: A Guide to Good Practice, usually called BR 209 or the BRE guide, is published by the Building Research Establishment. The first edition appeared in 1991, the second in 2011 and the third, which is the current one, in June 2022. It was written to help designers lay out new buildings so that they and their neighbours get reasonable daylight and sunlight. It was not written as a planning rulebook, but that is what it has become. Almost every local plan in England and Wales refers to it, the London Plan guidance is built on it and inspectors apply it at appeal.

What it covers

  • The effect of new development on the daylight to existing buildings, through the 25 degree rule, the vertical sky component and the no sky line
  • The effect on sunlight to existing buildings, through annual and winter probable sunlight hours
  • Overshadowing of gardens and open spaces, with the 21 March two hour test
  • Daylight and sunlight within new dwellings, following BS EN 17037
  • Extensions to existing buildings, through the 45 degree rule
  • Passive solar design and solar panels, with appendices on the calculation methods and on the interaction with rights of light

What changed in 2022

The structure and most of the neighbour tests carried over from 2011 with their targets unchanged: 27 per cent VSC, the 0.8 ratios, 25 per cent and 5 per cent sunlight hours, two hours on 21 March. The main change was to new dwellings, where the old average daylight factor targets were replaced by the illuminance targets of BS EN 17037, converted to daylight factor by location. The sunlight requirement for new homes became at least 1.5 hours on 21 March to a habitable room. The 2022 edition also clarified the treatment of windows under balconies, said more about applying the targets flexibly in dense urban areas and expanded the guidance on how to report results. Our daylight factor guide explains the new home targets.

How councils use it

A planning authority asks for a daylight and sunlight assessment where a scheme is close to neighbouring windows, taller than its surroundings or creates new homes. It expects the assessment to follow the BRE methods. The case officer reads the before and after tables, looks for ratios below 0.8 and weighs any shortfall against the context. Local policies sometimes add their own gloss: several London boroughs have supplementary guidance saying what VSC figures are typical for their streets. The London Plan guidance on housing design says the BRE targets should be applied with regard to the density expected in the location.

Guidance, not law

The guide says of itself that its numerical targets are to be interpreted flexibly, that they are advisory and that natural lighting is only one of many factors in site layout. That sentence is quoted in almost every planning decision where a scheme does not meet the recommendations and is approved anyway. It cuts both ways. An applicant cannot treat a ratio of 0.81 as a pass that ends the discussion. An objector cannot treat a ratio of 0.79 as a refusal. What decides the case is whether the loss is material to the rooms concerned in the setting concerned. That is a matter of judgement for which the guide provides the evidence. Our guide to the tests explains how each result is read.

BRE 209 and rights of light

The guide has an appendix on rights to light and is clear that its own tests are not the legal test. A right to light is measured by the Waldram method and is a private matter between owners, unaffected by planning permission. A scheme can meet the BRE targets and still infringe a neighbour’s right, which is why a developer who has had a clean daylight report should not assume the rights of light position is equally clean.

Getting an assessment

We prepare daylight and sunlight assessments to the 2022 guide for extensions, conversions, infill houses and flatted schemes, written for the case officer and quoted within 24 hours from the drawings. Where the council has already raised the guide, send us its comments as well and we will address them directly.

Frequently asked questions

5

Is BRE 209 mandatory?

No. It is guidance. Councils adopt it through their local plans and give it significant weight, but its targets are not legal limits.

5

What is the difference between BRE 209 and BS EN 17037?

BS EN 17037 is the British and European standard for daylight in buildings. BRE 209 is the practical guide that applies it, with other tests, to site layout and planning. The 2022 edition of BRE 209 adopts the standard’s targets for new homes.

5

Where can I get a copy of BRE 209?

It is sold by the BRE bookshop. Councils and planning consultants hold copies and most assessments quote the relevant paragraphs.

5

Which edition should an assessment use?

The 2022 third edition. An assessment still using the 2011 average daylight factor targets for new homes is out of date.

Get in Touch

We will be in touch to discuss your situation within one working day, free of charge.

    *Note - We will not share your personal details with any third parties, and you will not receive any email communication from us outside of direct correspondence in relation to your enquiry.

    Our Location

    Blue Sky Surveyors
    Office 7, 35-37 Ludgate Hill
    London
    EC4M 7JN

    Contact Information

    Phone: +020 7867 3955
    Email: info@rightsoflightsurveyors.co.uk

    BRE 209 Explained: The Daylight and Sunlight Guide