Right to Light Compensation: How It Is Worked Out
Most rights of light matters end with a payment rather than a court order: the neighbour releases their right over the scheme as drawn and the developer pays for it. This guide explains how surveyors arrive at the figure, what the book value method is, why the negotiation is about the uplift and how the courts approach damages when a case does get that far.
Two different things called compensation
The first is a negotiated release. The neighbour agrees, in a deed, to give up their right to light to the extent the scheme infringes it, in return for a payment. No court is involved and the figure is whatever the two sides agree, informed by the methods below. The second is damages awarded by a court instead of an injunction, where the judge has found an infringement and decided that money rather than an order is the right remedy. Both start from the same measurement of the loss. The negotiated release is by far the more common.
Step one: measure the loss
Everything begins with the Waldram calculation. For each affected room the surveyor produces the adequately lit area before and after the development. The difference is the loss. Because light at the front of the room, near the window, is worth more than light at the back, the room is divided into zones and the loss in each zone is weighted: losses nearest the window count for more than their area and losses in the rear makeweight zone count for a fraction. The result is a single figure for the room, expressed as an equivalent area of first zone light, usually in square feet. The figures for every room in the property are added together.
Step two: the book value
The weighted loss is then turned into money by the method the profession has used for decades. The lost light is treated as if it were lost floor space let at a notional rent, the light standard rent, which by long convention is a few pounds per square foot a year; £5 has been the usual figure for many years and in practice neither side argues about it. That annual sum is capitalised at a yield to give a capital figure, the book value. On a typical domestic case the book value comes out in the low thousands of pounds. On a large commercial infringement it can be in the tens or hundreds of thousands.
Step three: the uplift
The book value is where the negotiation starts, not where it ends. It reflects the neighbour’s loss, but it takes no account of what the developer gains from being allowed to build the infringing part of the scheme. Since the courts began awarding damages by reference to the developer’s profit, the practice has been to apply an uplift to the book value, a multiple that reflects the strength of the neighbour’s position, the value of the floorspace the developer keeps and how much the developer wants certainty. The uplift is what the two surveyors negotiate. It is where the experience of the surveyor acting for you makes the difference. A neighbour whose loss is small and whose room is a secondary one has little bargaining power; a neighbour whose living room is going below half lit, in a scheme that cannot be redesigned, has a great deal.
What the courts have done
Where a court awards damages instead of an injunction, it can assess them either as the fall in the value of the neighbour’s property or as the sum the neighbour could reasonably have demanded for releasing the right, which brings the developer’s gain into the calculation. In Tamares v Fairpoint (2007) the court took a share of the profit attributable to the infringing part of the building as its starting point. Other cases have awarded sums far above the book value on the same reasoning. None of this means a court will award damages at all: the primary remedy remains the injunction. Our guide to injunctions explains when the courts have refused to accept money. Whether a given infringement would end in an injunction or in damages and at what level is for the court. A neighbour considering a claim should take a solicitor’s advice.
Who pays the fees
In a settlement the developer normally pays the neighbour’s reasonable surveying and legal fees as a separate item, at cost, alongside the release payment. That is why a neighbour with a real loss can usually have the figures checked and the release negotiated without paying for it themselves. We say so at the first conversation. We say equally plainly when a loss is too small to be worth pursuing.
For developers
The same arithmetic tells a developer what a scheme is likely to cost to clear. A rights of light report with the book values for every affected room and a view on the likely uplifts is the figure to put in the appraisal before planning rather than after. Where the total is high, it is often cheaper to lose a bay or a storey than to pay for it. Where it is modest, insurance may be the better route.
If you are planning a scheme, the cheapest time to deal with rights of light is before the design is fixed. Send us the drawings and we will say which neighbouring windows are at risk and what the options are, from adjusting the massing to a release or insurance.
Frequently asked questions
How much compensation can I get for loss of light?
It depends on the measured loss, the rooms affected and the developer’s position. Small domestic losses settle for modest sums; serious losses to living rooms in schemes that cannot be changed settle for much more. A survey gives the starting figure.
What is the light standard rent?
A notional annual rent applied to the weighted area of lost light to produce a capital value. By convention it has been £5 per square foot for many years.
Do I have to accept compensation?
No. A neighbour cannot be forced to release a right. The alternative is to leave the right in place, which may lead to the scheme being changed or to court proceedings.
Who pays my surveyor?
In a settlement the developer usually pays the neighbour’s reasonable surveying and legal fees at cost, in addition to the release payment.
Is compensation taxable?
A payment for releasing a right over your home may have tax consequences depending on your circumstances. That is a question for an accountant or solicitor rather than a surveyor.
Get in Touch
We will be in touch to discuss your situation within one working day, free of charge.
Our Location
Office 7, 35-37 Ludgate Hill
London
EC4M 7JN
Contact Information
Email: info@rightsoflightsurveyors.co.uk